Solid 4-star property in a 5-star location. Perhaps not as posh as some other properties in the area, but for what we paid we feel it was far and away the best value. Very cool 30's - 50's vintage vibe. Rooms not big but clean and with a comfie bed and climate controls. On-site dining not mind-blowing but good enough. Staff friendly and accommodating, and a big plus for us was a very effective, very speedy elevator system. In summation, a lot going for this place, but the best part, bar none, is the location! It is literally across the street from the Richard Rodgers theater (where Hamilton is playing) and next door to the Lena Horne theater (where Six is playing). Pretty much all other on-Broadway shows are within walking distance, and Times Square is less than 100 yards away.
If you are looking for a reliable, comfortable, clean hotel in a nearly perfect location that won't break the bank, this is about as good as it gets.